Halacha for Thursday 25 Tishrei 5783 October 20 2022

Until When Must One Retain the Prozbul?

At the end of the previous year, we have explained in the context of the Halacha Yomit that any debt one is owed by another which is already due to be repaid which the Shemitta year passes over, immediately at the conclusion of the Shemitta year, the debt is canceled. We have also discussed that the debts owed to one who has filled out a Prozbul are not canceled by Shevi’it.

Just as one may fill out a Prozbul himself, one may likewise appoint an agent to do so on one’s behalf, for instance, one may request from the rabbi of one’s community to fill out a Prozbul on one’s behalf. Two Shemittot ago, (5768/2008), Maran zt”l instructed us that we may accept powers of attorney through our website “Halacha Yomit” for anyone interested in doing so authorizing us as their agent to fill out the Prozbul. Indeed, we had filled out thousands of Prozbul contracts that year on behalf of our members.

Now, let us discuss an interesting question we have received regarding the above law:

Question: How is it that one may appoint an agent to fill out a Prozbul on one’s behalf, for when the lender comes to claim repayment of the loan from the borrower, the borrower can claim that the debt has already been canceled by Shevi’it and the lender will not be able to counter-claim that he has already filled out a Prozbul and the debt has not been canceled because he does not have the Prozbul in his hands to show?! This brings about another question: Until when must one retain the Prozbul contract? Forever?

Answer: The Borrower’s Claim
Indeed, if a borrower comes once Shevi’it has passed and claims to his lender that the debt has already been canceled with the conclusion of the Shemitta year, his claim is correct according to Torah law and the lender has lost the debt owed to him. Nevertheless, this only applies when the lender has not written a Prozbul; however, if he has written one, although the lender does not have it in his hand at the time, he is believed to claim that he has filled out a Prozbul by means of an agent. This law is derived from a similar Halacha, as we shall now discuss.

I Had a Prozbul and I Lost It
The Gemara (Gittin 37b) states that Rav Nachman said that one is believed to claim that “I had a Prozbul, but I lost it,” for since our Sages enacted the Prozbul contract, “one does not leave the permissible and eat the forbidden.” This means that if one comes to collect a debt and the borrower claims that the debt has already been canceled by Shevi’it, the lender is believed to say that he filled out a Prozbul, but it was lost. The reason the lender is believed to say this is because we have a strong assumption that an upstanding individual does not leave a permissible object in favor of a forbidden object when he has a choice. Thus, since our Sages enacted the Prozbul contract through which one will be able to collect one’s debts in a permissible fashion, there is no reason to be concerned that one will leave the permissible way to collect one’s debts in favor of collecting one’s debts without writing a Prozbul in a forbidden manner. Rather, we believe the lender and since he had a permissible manner to collect his debts through filling out a Prozbul, he must certainly have done so; he may therefore collect his debt. Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch (Choshen Mishpat, Chapter 67, Section 33) rules likewise.

Based on the above, the same would apply in our case and since there is no necessity to actually present the Prozbul contract in Bet Din, for the actual Prozbul contract is not required as a proof that it was filled out and the claim of “I had filled out a Prozbul but I lost it” is sufficient, thus, even if one claims that one has filled out a Prozbul by means of the “Halacha Yomit” website or any other agent, one will be believed and Bet Din will rule that one is halachically permitted to collect one’s debts.

Summary: One may appoint a messenger to fill out a Prozbul on one’s behalf. Any Prozbul contract filled out by an agent one behalf of another need not actually make its way to the hands of the lender. Rather, once the agent fills out the Prozbul in accordance with Halacha, the lender will be believed with this claim in Bet Din, and he will be able to collect his debts in accordance with Torah law.

8 Halachot Most Popular

The “Hashkivenu” Blessing on Shabbat Night

Question: Why is it that on Shabbat night we recite a different text within the “Hashkivenu” blessing and why do we recite “Ve’Shameru Beneh Yisrael Et Ha’Shabbat” afterwards? Answer: During the weekday Arvit prayers, after “Ga’al Yisrael” ble......

Read Halacha

Praying Mincha After Accepting Shabbat

Question: If when I arrived at the synagogue on Friday evening, I realized that the congregation had already accepted Shabbat (through Kabbalat Shabbat), however, the sun had not yet set. May I still pray Mincha for Friday? Answer: Let us first discuss the basis of this question, as delineated by......

Read Halacha

One Who Hears Thunder at Night- One Blessing

In the previous Halacha we have established that one who sees lightning recites the blessing, “Baruch Ata Hashem Elokeinu Melech Ha’Olam Oseh Ma’aseh Bereshit.” One who hears thunder recites the blessing, “Baruch Ata Hashem Elokeinu Melech Ha’Olam Shekocho Ugvurat......

Read Halacha

Hosha’ana Rabba

The Final Judgment and the Custom to Remain Awake All Night The primary days of judgment are from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur, however, Hosha’ana Rabba which is the seventh day of the Sukkot festival, one’s judgment for the coming year is completely sealed. The prevalent custom amon......

Read Halacha


Women and the Mussaf Prayer

Question: May women recite the Mussaf prayer on Shabbat? Answer: We have been asked this question several times recently and thus, let us now explain this matter. The Reason Why Women Are Obligated to Pray Women are obligated to pray one prayer daily, as we have explained in the Halacha regar......

Read Halacha

Question: May one recite the Amida prayer in front of a curtain (covering the Aron Kodesh) which is adorned with various designs?

Answer: The Rambam writes in one of his responses (Freiman edition, Chapter 20): “It is incorrect to pray in front of garments with designs on them, even if the designs are not protruding. We usually close our eyes when it happens that we must pray in front of a wall or garment adorned with de......

Read Halacha

Chol Ha’Mo’ed

The days between the first and seventh days (outside of Israel between the second and eighth days) of the Pesach holiday and the days between the first day of Sukkot and the holiday of Shemini Atzeret (outside of Israel between the second day of Sukkot and Shemini Atzeret) are called “Chol Ha&......

Read Halacha

Washing One’s Hands After Visiting the Graves of Righteous Individuals

Question: Must one wash one’s hands after visiting the graves of righteous individuals or visiting a cemetery? Is the obligation to do so specifically after visiting a cemetery or is one obligated to do so even after participating in a funeral? Answer: Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch (Chapter......

Read Halacha