Halacha for Thursday 23 Cheshvan 5783 November 17 2022

Selecting in Terms of Separating Grapes or Tomatoes from their Cluster

Question: If among a cluster of grapes there are several rotten ones, may one remove the rotten grapes from the cluster so that only the good and edible ones remain?

Answer: In previous Halachot we have explained that it is forbidden to select waste from food on Shabbat, even if this is being done with the intention to eat the food immediately, as we have discussed.

Regarding a cluster of grapes (or cherry tomatoes for that matter) which contains several rotten grapes, clearly, one may not remove the bad grapes from the cluster as this constitutes selecting waste from food, for the bad grapes are “waste” and the good grapes are “food.” Thus, Maran zt”l rules that removing the bad grapes from the cluster is indeed a Torah prohibition.

This applies even if the rotten grapes are not so rotten and are still edible and one merely does not wish to eat them; it is nevertheless certainly forbidden to remove them on Shabbat, for, as we have already explained, any item one does not desire is considered “waste” relative to the item one does desire. (Nevertheless, in this instance the prohibition is only rabbinic in nature and is not a Torah prohibition.)

A certain great rabbi rules leniently on this matter and has brought a source for this based on what several Rishonim write that one may separate forbidden fats (found on certain cuts of meat from the hindquarters of the animal) from meat on Yom Tov. The reason for this is because the forbidden fat is attached to the meat and according to some, selecting does not apply to something which is attached.

Maran Rabbeinu Ovadia Yosef zt”l disagrees with his opinion and writes that there is a great distinction between meat which is actually attached to the forbidden fat and a bunch of grapes which are attached to a cluster (stem): Regarding meat attached to forbidden fat, separating the fat from the meat is tantamount to removing a fruit from the peel which surrounds it to which selecting does not apply. However, removing grapes from their cluster is not similar to peeling a fruit at all.

Summary: Regarding a cluster of grapes which contains some good grapes and some which are not so good, it is forbidden to separate the bad grapes and leave only the good ones, for this constitutes selecting “waste” from “food” which is forbidden. Therefore, one should remove the good grapes and eat them; afterwards, one may dispose of the stem with the bad grapes. The same applies to a cluster of cherry tomatoes which contains some good tomatoes and some rotten or green ones; one may not remove the bad ones first; rather, one must remove the good ones first, as we have explained.

8 Halachot Most Popular

The Most Awesome Day of the Year

An Excerpt from a Discourse Delivered by Maran zt”l in the Chazon Ovadia Synagogue in Rechavia, Jerusalem on the Night of Yom Kippur It is quoted in the name of a great sage who made a play on words using the words of the Mishnah, “Did you tithe? Did you make an Eruv? Light the candle......

Read Halacha

The Obligation to Eat in the Sukkah

A Meal of an Established Character Throughout the entire Sukkot holiday, both during the night and day, it is prohibited to eat a meal of an established character outside of the Sukkah. The amount of food one is required to eat in order for one’s meal to constitute a “meal of an establi......

Read Halacha

The “Hashkivenu” Blessing on Shabbat Night

Question: Why is it that on Shabbat night we recite a different text within the “Hashkivenu” blessing and why do we recite “Ve’Shameru Beneh Yisrael Et Ha’Shabbat” afterwards? Answer: During the weekday Arvit prayers, after “Ga’al Yisrael” ble......

Read Halacha

Hosha’ana Rabba

The Final Judgment and the Custom to Remain Awake All Night The primary days of judgment are from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur, however, Hosha’ana Rabba which is the seventh day of the Sukkot festival, one’s judgment for the coming year is completely sealed. The prevalent custom amon......

Read Halacha


Chol Ha’Mo’ed

The days between the first and seventh days (outside of Israel between the second and eighth days) of the Pesach holiday and the days between the first day of Sukkot and the holiday of Shemini Atzeret (outside of Israel between the second day of Sukkot and Shemini Atzeret) are called “Chol Ha&......

Read Halacha

Washing One’s Hands After Visiting the Graves of Righteous Individuals

Question: Must one wash one’s hands after visiting the graves of righteous individuals or visiting a cemetery? Is the obligation to do so specifically after visiting a cemetery or is one obligated to do so even after participating in a funeral? Answer: Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch (Chapter......

Read Halacha

The Walls of the Sukkah

The days between Yom Kippur and the Sukkot holiday are indeed holy ones during which we are involved with the building of the Sukkah in order to go from strength to strength. Our Sages teach us that the four days between Yom Kippur and Sukkot are treated as sanctified days and are similar to the day......

Read Halacha

Washing One’s Hands for Less than a Kebeitza of Bread

In the previous Halacha we have cited Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch who rules that if one eats less than a Kezayit (twenty-seven grams) of bread, one need not wash his hands. (These twenty-seven grams of bread are calculated as if one would take bread and squash it tightly into a baby bottle such th......

Read Halacha