Halacha for Sunday 19 Adar 5779 February 24 2019

Question: May one board an inter-city train on Friday (before the onset of Shabbat) when one knows that the train will continue to travel on Shabbat?

Answer: Our question consists of several different aspects. Firstly, conducting a train on Shabbat is a grave Torah prohibition consisting of igniting a flame on Shabbat, for when one presses on the gas or electric pedal, a combustion is created; this constitutes a prohibition of Shabbat desecration similar to driving a car on Shabbat.

This transgression alone certainly prohibits such a train ride on Shabbat when the conductor or most of the passengers are Jewish. However, it would seem that there should be room for leniency when the conductor and most of the passengers are non-Jewish, which is the case regarding trains in Europe, the United States, and the like, for an additional Jewish passenger does not create any additional Shabbat desecration with regards to the combustion in the engine since the Jew’s weight is certainly vastly outnumbered by the weight of the train itself along with all its other passengers. Thus, this alone would not be sufficient to render the train ride prohibited.

Nevertheless, another prohibition does indeed exist, which is the prohibition of exiting one’s boundaries on Shabbat. This means that it is forbidden for one to leave the boundaries of the city one is currently within and enter the boundaries of another city. Since the train is passing from one city to another on Shabbat itself, riding on such a train is completely forbidden. Although one is physically not doing anything and is merely sitting in a moving train being driven by a non-Jewish conductor, nevertheless, the Ritba writes that such a thing is forbidden on Shabbat (since one has entered the moving object willingly on Erev Shabbat) and it is considered as though one is physically walking on the ground himself. Many other great Rishonim rule likewise regarding riding on a wagon steered by a non-Jew on Shabbat. Indeed, Hagaon Chatam Sofer rules likewise regarding riding on a train on Shabbat and writes that although the prohibition riding an animal on Shabbat does not apply here, for a train is not an animal and neither is there any prohibition regarding the actual riding of the train, for a non-Jewish conductor is doing all of the forbidden works on his own for the majority of the passengers who are non-Jewish, nevertheless, this is forbidden due to the prohibition of leaving one’s boundaries on Shabbat. Hagaon Rabbeinu Abdallah Somech zt”l of Baghdad, Maran zt”l, and many great other Acharonim rule likewise.

Another reason to forbid such a train ride on Shabbat is because one usually carries personal items along with him, such as money, train tickets, and the like, which is likewise another reason to completely prohibit this on Shabbat.

In the following Halacha we shall discuss the law regarding an electric train which does not cross various boundaries, such as an inner-city train or subway.

Ask the Rabbi

8 Halachot Most Popular

Reciting Birkat Hamazon While Walking on One’s Way

Question: If one is eating while walking outdoors, may one recite Birkat Hamazon while continuing to walk? Answer: In the previous Halacha we have discussed that our Sages have enacted that one must recite Birkat Hamazon while sitting in order for the individual to have maximum concentration. ......

Read Halacha

The Significance of Tu Bishvat

The Fifteenth of Shevat or Tu Bishvat is the Rosh Hashanah for trees (Rosh Hashanah 2a). Most people commonly think that just as on the First of Tishrei, which is the day of Rosh Hashanah, all creations are judged for life or death, for wealth or poverty, and the like, so too, on Tu Bishvat, trees a......

Read Halacha

Reciting Birkat Hamazon While Seated

Question: Is one obligated to sit while reciting Birkat Hamazon or is it permissible to recite it while walking as well? Answer: The Gemara in Masechet Berachot (51b) states that one must recite Birkat Hamazon while seated. The Poskim as well as Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch (Chapter 183) rule li......

Read Halacha

A Dish Comprised of Several Kinds of Food

Question: What is the correct blessing on stuffed peppers? Similarly, what is the correct blessing on a cake which has just a little flour but the primary ingredients of the cake are fruits and nuts? Answer: In the previous Halacha we have explained that when one eats two different foods requirin......

Read Halacha

Foods Which Contain Flour

During the past few days, we have discussed that when a dish is comprised of several different foods which require different blessings, one should recite the blessing on the primary food in the dish. Thus, if one eats grape leaves stuffed with rice, one should recite the Mezonot blessing, for the ri......

Read Halacha

The Law that the Blessing on a Primary Food Exempts a Secondary Food

Next Sunday night marks Tu Bishvat, a day we customarily recite many blessings. We shall therefore discuss the laws of blessing for the next several days. The Mishnah in Masechet Berachot (44a) states: “The rule is: If there is a primary food and a secondary food along with it, one recites ......

Read Halacha

The Laws of a Primary and Secondary Food Regarding Blessings

Question: If one eats a slice of bread along with fish, is it possible that one only recites a blessing on the fish and the bread will be considered secondary to the fish and exempted by it? Answer: In the previous Halacha we have explained the basic laws of primary and secondary foods regarding ......

Read Halacha

The Order for Lighting Shabbat and Chanukah Candles

There is a disagreement among the Rishonim as to the order of lighting Shabbat and Chanukah candles on Erev Shabbat Chanukah. The Ba’al Halachot Gedolot (commonly referred to as “Behag”) is of the opinion that Chanukah candles must be lit before Shabbat candles because women cu......

Read Halacha