Halacha for miércoles 12 Adar 5781 24 February 2021

The Mitzvah of the Purim Feast This Year (5781)

Holding the Purim Feast at Night
The holiday of Purim is different than all other holidays we celebrate in that whereas regarding other holidays the Mitzvah of partaking of a joyous holiday meal applies during the day and night, regarding the holiday of Purim, there is only a Mitzvah to hold a feast during the day, not at night. Nevertheless, several Rishonim write that there is a Mitzvah to have a meal on the night of Purim as well as we find by all other holidays. This is indeed the opinion of the Geonim. Halachically speaking, however, the primary Purim feast must be held specifically during the day. If one holds his Purim feast only at night, one has not fulfilled one’s obligation, as the verse states, “Days of feasting and merriment,” which teaches us that the feast must be held during the day. When the meal is held during the day, it should be held in a well-lit area amid much joy and speaking words of Torah. One should indeed be glad with what Hashem has provided him, that he has separated us from those who have gone astray, and that He has given us His true and eternal Torah which provides us with good and just laws to follow in order to allow us entry into the World to Come.

The Proper Time for the Purim Feast
The proper time to hold the Purim feast every year is during the day, as we have mentioned. The Poskim point out that one should preferably not hold the Purim feast close to sunset, i.e. close to the end of Purim, for then, the primary joy would not be experienced during the day of Purim at all. Therefore, they write that one should try to begin the Purim feast as early as possible. There are several other reasons for this as well.

Many have the custom to pray Mincha Gedola, i.e. praying Mincha at an early hour, and to begin their Purim feast immediately thereafter. Those who are truly meticulous about their Mitzvah observance hold their Purim feast in the morning, before the time for Mincha prayers arrives. This is indeed the opinion of several Poskim, including the saintly Shelah, who write that one should hold one’s Purim meal early on in the day; the earlier one holds the feast, the more praiseworthy he is.

This was indeed the custom of Maran Rabbeinu Ovadia Yosef zt”l who would partake of his Purim feast immediately following Shacharit prayers as he would on Shabbat day, in accordance with the opinion of the saintly Shelah. Nevertheless, according to the letter of the law, it is permissible to begin this feast later on in the day as is the prevalent custom.

The Proper Time for the Purim Feast This Year
This year, 5781, the holiday of Purim, which is on the 14th of Adar, falls this coming Thursday night and Friday. In walled-cities from the days of Yehoshua bin Nun, meaning in the holy city of Jerusalem, Purim will fall out on the 15th of Adar, namely this coming Shabbat, in which case a “three-day Purim” is celebrated, as we shall discuss in the following Halacha.

The Rama (Chapter 695, Section 2) writes that in this case, the Purim feast should be held at an early hour of the day in honor of Shabbat, so that one will be able to partake of the Shabbat meal heartily and not while one is still satisfied and tired from the Purim feast. Hagaon Mishnah Berura rules likewise that when Purim falls out on a Friday, one should hold the Purim feast in the morning before halachic midday (which is at approximately 12:10 PM).

The great Rishon Le’Zion, Hagaon Harav Yitzchak Yosef Shlit”a writes (in his Yalkut Yosef, Chapter 695) that according to the letter of the law, one may hold the Purim feast even later in the afternoon since this meal is considered a Mitzvah and a Seudat Mitzvah at its appropriate time may be held even on Friday afternoon.

Nevertheless, he quotes the Sefer Yosef Ometz who writes that when Purim falls out on a Friday, having the Purim feast after halachic midday detracts from the honor of Shabbat and thus, the “primary” part of the meal should be held in the morning. This means that the Purim feast should at least be started in the morning so that in the afternoon, one will only eat a small amount, all in honor of Shabbat. He writes that this is indeed the custom in Jerusalem where the Purim feast is held in the morning. The other Mitzvot of the day, namely Mishloach Manot and Matanot La’Evyonim should be performed before the feast.  

If one did not have a chance to hold one’s Purim feast in the morning, one should do so as soon as possible; one should try to make it as early as possible in honor of Shabbat.

Summary: The Purim feast must be held during the day, not at night. It is preferable to hold the feast as early on in the day as possible in order to be able to partake of the Shabbat night meal with a hearty appetite. If one has not done so, the meal should be held as soon thereafter as possible.

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

ORDEN RITUAL DE LA NOCHE DE ROSH HASHANA

Las dos noches de Rosh Hashana es costumbre comer alimentos que simbolizan buenos designios para Israel. Por ello se come Rubia o lubia en árabe, zapallo –calabaza dulce-, dátiles, acelga, puerro, cabeza de cordero, manzana y miel. Ya hemos escrito oportunamente, que la perso......

Read Halacha

EL SHOFAR

Es un precepto de la Torá oír los sonidos del Shofar el día de Rosh Hashana, como está escrito: Día de Teruá será para ustedes. A partir de que se oyen las bendiciones correspondientes está absolutamente prohibido hablar hasta que finalicen ......

Read Halacha

LA SALIDA DE QUIPUR

Al terminar el sagrado día de Quipur es necesario, según enseñan nuestros sabios, agregar unos minutos al día, de manera de no culminar la santidad del mismo en forma inmediata con la salida de las estrellas. Como vimos en otras ocasiones, lo ideal de acuerdo a la postura......

Read Halacha

SOBRE EL PRECEPTO DE COMER EN LA SUCÁ

Es un precepto de la Torá comer un “cazait” (27 grs.) de pan la primera noche de Sucot dentro de la Sucá (ver Talmud Sucá 27ª). Este cazait de pan debe ser consumido en un tiempo máximo de 4 a 5 minutos. Eventualmente, si lo consume en un lapso de siet......

Read Halacha


SOBRE COMER Y BAÑARSE EN QUIPUR

Es una obligación para cada individuo de Israel ayunar el día de Quipur. Incluso las mujeres embarazadas y las que están amamantando deben ayunar, a menos que se hayan impedidas de hacerlo. De todas maneras, cada situación en especial debe consultarse con un rabino expert......

Read Halacha

PERMANENCIA AL LADO DE QUIEN SE HALLA EN MEDIO DE SU AMIDÁ

En la entrega anterior aclaramos que está permitido, según disposición estrictamente halájica sentarse durante la Hazará. Ahora veremos de aclarar otra halajá que se halla íntimamente relacionada con ésta, y es el sentarse a un lado de quien se......

Read Halacha

ESTA PERMITIDO CONSUMIR PESCADO CON LECHE?

Estudiamos en el Talmud, tratado de Hulin 103b, se prohíbe cocinar carnes con leche, a excepción de la carne de pescado y de langosta. Observamos entonces que, de acuerdo a la legislación talmúdica no se incluye en la prohibición de consumir o cocinar carne con lec......

Read Halacha

ORDEN SEGÚN EL QUE SE PROCEDE LA NOCHE DE ROSH HASHANA

Se acostumbra los dos noches de Rosh Hashana consumir distintos alimentos cuyos nombres transmiten buenos augurios para el año entrante. Por ello, es costumbre comer la primera noche de Rosh Hashana Rubia –porotos alubias-, llamados en árabe lubie, zapallo o calabaza, puerro o a......

Read Halacha