Halacha for jeudi 9 Tevet 5781 24 December 2020

The Fast of the Tenth of Tevet When it Coincides With Erev Shabbat

Tomorrow, Friday, will mark the Tenth of Tevet, a public fast day observed throughout the Jewish nation until the arrival of Mashiach which marks the day the king of Babylon besieged Jerusalem with the intent of destroying it. The verse (Yechezkel 24) states: “And the word of Hashem was to me in the ninth year during the tenth month (Tevet) on the tenth day, saying: ‘Son of man! Write for yourself the name of the day, the essence of this very day, for on this very day the king of Babylon laid siege to Jerusalem.’”

The Sages disagree in Masechet Eruvin (40b) what the proper protocol is for when the Tenth of Tevet coincides with Friday, Erev Shabbat. Should the Jewish nation be fasting as we would if the Tenth of Tevet fell out on any other day of the week or perhaps, one should break the fast slightly before the conclusion of Shabbat in honor of Shabbat so as not to enter Shabbat while fasting?

The Gemara (ibid.) quotes a Baraita: “Rabbi Yehuda said: Once, we were sitting before Rabbi Akiva and it was the Ninth of Av which coincided with Erev Shabbat (this cannot happen anymore based on the way our current calendar was set up; however, in the times of Rabbi Akiva, who established the years and months on his own, this was indeed possible). They brought him a slightly cooked egg and he swallowed it without salt. It was not that he desired it; rather, he wished to show the students the Halacha. However, Rabbi Yose said: One must fast and complete the fast.”

This means that Rabbi Akiva broke his fast several minutes before the onset of Shabbat in order to teach the students that one should not enter Shabbat suffering and fasting, for this is considered disrespectful to Shabbat. Nevertheless, Rabbi Yose disagreed with Rabbi Yehuda and ruled that one must complete the fast, as usual.

The Gemara concludes that the Halacha follows the opinion of Rabbi Yose and one must complete the entire fast and eat nothing until Shabbat night Kiddush.

Indeed, the Tosafot quote Rabbeinu Chananel as saying that we have a tradition that Rabbi Akiva was dangerously ill that year and the doctors brought him some food toward the end of the fast. However, Rabbi Yehuda was not aware of this fact and he relied solely on what he saw and he did not know the reason why Rabbi Akiva ate. Thus, even according to Rabbi Akiva, there is no leniency in this regard.

Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch (Chapter 249) rules that when a fast day coincides with Erev Shabbat, one must complete the entire fast and one may not eat before Shabbat begins.

Thus, Maran Rabbeinu Ovadia Yosef zt”l writes (in his Chazon Ovadia- Arba Ta’aniyot, page 15) that if the congregation prays Mincha and Arvit earlier on Friday afternoon in the synagogue, they may still not make Kiddush until nightfall, which is at approximately fifteen minutes past sunset.

Nevertheless, Hagaon Harav David Yosef Shlit”a writes in his Halacha Berura that according to all opinions, one may not purposely prolong fasting into Shabbat and therefore, Mincha, Kabbalat Shabbat, and Arvit prayers should begin slightly earlier than usual in the synagogue and the Chazzan should move through the prayers quicker than usual so that the congregation can make their way home and recite Kiddush as close to nightfall as possible.

Ask the Rabbi

8 Halachot Most Popular

Les 8 niveaux de la Tsédaka

Le RAMBAM écrit (chap.10 des règles relatives aux dons aux nécessiteux): Il y a 8 niveaux dans la Tsédaka, l’un supérieur à l’autre. C'est-à-dire: 8 façons de donner la Tsédaka, l’une supérieure à l&......

Read Halacha

Mitsva de Tsédaka et du Ma’asser Késsafim

A la demande de nombreuses personnes, nous continuons à développer le sujet de la Mitsva de Tsédaka et du Ma’asser Késsafim (dîme financière), à partir des propos de MARAN l’auteur du Choulh’an ‘Arouh’ et des décisi......

Read Halacha

Déduire du Ma’asser les dépenses liées aux enfants

Question: Les personnes qui ont l’usage de prélever chaque mois le « Ma’asser Késsafim » (la dîme financière), peuvent-elles déduire du Ma’asser, les frais de prise en charge de leurs enfants qui vivent encore avec eux? R&e......

Read Halacha

Quelle est la quantité que l’on doit donner à la Tsédaka?

Concernant la quantité que l’on doit donner à la Tsédaka, nos maîtres - le RAMBAM, le TOUR et MARAN l’auteur du Choulh'an ‘Arouh’ – écrivent que lorsqu’on possède les moyens suffisants, il faut donner selon les besoins ......

Read Halacha

Qui est soumis à l’obligation de donner la Tsédaka

Toute personne du peuple d’Israël est soumise à l’obligation de donner la Tsédaka. Même le nécessiteux qui se nourrit de la Tsédaka, qui n’a pas d’autre moyen de se nourrir, et dont toute la subsistance provient de ce que lui donnent le......

Read Halacha

La Mitsva de Tsédaka – Notre maitre le Rav z.ts.l

Notre maitre le TOUR écrit: La Mitsva de Tsédaka incombe chaque membre du peuple d’Israël, en donnant de son argent, selon ses possibilités. Hormis le fait que toute personne qui donne la Tsédaka, accompli une ordonnance positive de la Torah, toute personne......

Read Halacha

Le mérite nécessaire pour donner de la Tsédaka – Le rêve extraordinaire

Dans la précédente Halacha, nous avons mentionné la demande du prophète Irméyahou auprès d’Hachem afin que lorsque les Récha’im (impies) désireront donner de la Tsédaka, Hachem les heurte à des gens incorrectes. Cela s......

Read Halacha

La Tsédaka envers des personnes incorrectes

Dans les précédentes Halachot, nous avons expliqué les principes de la Mitsva de Tsédaka. Une personne qui transgresse une des Mitsvot de la Torah et ne fait pas Téchouva, par exemple un homme qui a conscience de l’interdiction de se raser à la lame......

Read Halacha