Halacha for יום שני כ"ה כסלו תשפ"ב 29 בNovember 2021

Hallel on Chanukah as it Pertains to Women

Question: Since women are obligated to light Chanukah candles, does this mean that they are likewise obligated to recite the Hallel every morning of Chanukah as well?

Answer: Women are exempt from all positive, time-bound Mitzvot, such as eating in the Sukkah, taking the Lulav, and hearing the Shofar (as opposed to negative, time-bound commandments, such as eating on Yom Kippur or performing forbidden works on Shabbat, which they certainly are obligated to observe). There are certain Mitzvot which are exceptions to this rule but this is nevertheless the general rule.

Based on this, it seems that women should be exempt from lighting Chanukah candles, for this too is a positive, time-bound Mitzvah since it only applies on Chanukah.

Nevertheless, our Sages said that women are, in fact, obligated in the Mitzvah of lighting Chanukah candles, for when our Sages instituted this Mitzvah, this was done in order to publicize the miracle that Hashem performed for our ancestors in those days. Since women were included in this miracle, they were not excluded from the enactment of our Sages and they were likewise obligated to light Chanukah candles.

If so, it seems that the same should apply regarding the recitation of the Hallel throughout Chanukah, for reciting Hallel during the days of Chanukah is likewise a rabbinic enactment in order to publicize the miracle of Chanukah and to thank Hashem for it. Since women were included in this miracle, it seems that they should likewise be obligated to recite Hallel every day of Chanukah with a blessing.

Nevertheless, the Rambam and other Poskim write that women are exempt from reciting the Hallel on Chanukah. Maran Rabbeinu Ovadia Yosef zt”l explains this matter beautifully and writes that although women were included in the miracle of Chanukah, our Sages nonetheless did not wish to obligate them in the Mitzvah of reciting the Hallel, for there is a great distinction between the Mitzvah of lighting Chanukah candles and the Mitzvah of reciting the Hallel. Since lighting the Chanukah candles causes the miracle to be publicized in a grand manner for all passerby to see who will then remember the miracle Hashem performed for our forefathers, our Sages decided that it is correct that women be obligated to perform this Mitzvah as well. On the other hand, reciting the Hallel on Chanukah is strictly between man and his Creator and does not constitute as grand a publicization of the miracle and therefore, our Sages did not want to differentiate between the laws regarding reciting Hallel on Chanukah and reciting Hallel on any other holiday and they therefore exempt women from reciting Hallel on Chanukah (see Chazon Ovadia-Chanukah, page 214).

Summary: According to the law, women are exempt from reciting the Hallel on Chanukah. Nevertheless, women who recite Hallel after praying throughout the days of Chanukah are especially praiseworthy. However, they may not recite a blessing before doing so since they are not obligated to do so.

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

EL DIA DE TISHA BEAB

Durante el día de Tisha BeAb -9 de Ab- están prohibido cinco cosas, a saber: Comer y beber, calzar calzado de cuero, relaciones maritales, lavarse y ungirse (utilizar cremas, aceites, etc.). Asimismo está prohibido estudiar Torá este día, pues esto regocija a la pe......

Read Halacha

CON EL COMIENZO DEL MES DE AB SE DISMINUYEN LAS PRACTICAS ALEGRES

Aún cuando, como ya vimos anteriormente, desde el 17 de Tamuz se acostumbran alguna prácticas de duelo, al comenzar el mes de Ab esto se hace más estricto y las costumbres de duelo son más rígidas y se observan hasta el 10 de Ab. Afirma el Talmud (Ta´anit 26b......

Read Halacha

DURANTE LAS TRES SEMANAS

Está prohibido realizar festejos, bailes, etc, durante las tres semanas que transcurren desde el 17 d eTamuz hasta el 9 de Ab incluso sin instrumentos musicales. Esto es válido para los bailes o festejos que se organizan según las leyes del recato y la sobriedad del nuestro p......

Read Halacha

EL CONSUMO DE CARNE A PARTIR DE ROSH HODESH AB

Afirma el Talmud (Ta´anit 26b) que decretaron nuestros sabios que en la seudá hamafseket–última comida previa al ayuno- no se debe consumir carne ni beber vino así como no se deben comer dos comidas diferentes, por ej. arroz y huevo. Y aún cuando el Talmud pro......

Read Halacha


COSTUMBRES A PARTIR DEL 1 DE AB

Como vimos anteriormente a partir de R. Hodesh Ab se deben disminuir todas las transacciones comerciales destinadas a cuestiones de alegría. Escribe nuestro maestro R. Ovadia Yosef z”l que no se deben adquirir sortijas o anillos de oro, especialmente los novios que adquieren estas jo......

Read Halacha

QUIENES AYUNAN EL 9 DE AB

El enfermo, aún cuando no se halla en situación de peligro su vida está exento de ayunar en Tisha Beab. De todas formas, ante cualquier duda se debe realizar una consulta rabínica ya que no cualquier tipo de malestar exime a la persona de ayunar. El anciano que se encu......

Read Halacha

COMO SE REALIZA LA TEBILAT KELIM

Se debe evitar la ”jatzitza” al sumergir el utensilio en la mikva. Jatzitza es todo elemento que evita el contacto directo del agua con el objeto. Por eso, no se debe asir el objeto que se sumerge fuertemente pues se estaría evitando que el agua haga contacto con el mismo en el lu......

Read Halacha

COMIDAS CARNICAS DESPUES DE COMIDAS LACTEAS

Anteriormente hemos visto que si se comió una comida cocinada con carne aún cuando no se comió carne se deben esperar seis horas para consumir lácteos. A continuación veremos la halajá inversa, es decir si se ha consumido comidas lácteas como aplica l......

Read Halacha