Halacha for Thursday 25 Iyar 5782 May 26 2022

Clapping and Drumming on a Table on Shabbat and Yom Tov

The Gemara in Masechet Beitzah (30a) states that one may not drum, clap, or dance on Shabbat lest one come to fix a musical instrument (ibid. 36b).

This means that just as we have discussed in the previous Halachot that our Sages have decreed that one may not play musical instruments on Shabbat lest one come to fix them on Shabbat by tuning the cords and the like, they have likewise banned all forms of sound production which resemble musical tunes on Shabbat.

Our Sages therefore forbade clapping one’s hands, dancing (as we shall soon discuss), and drumming on a table to the rhythm of a song on Shabbat, for all of these things are included in the prohibition of producing sound on Shabbat and Yom Tov.

We have already mentioned that the concern of our Sages that one will come to repair a musical instrument still applies nowadays, for musicians commonly “repair” their instruments by tuning their instruments and the like while they are playing.

However, the Tosafot write that the reason for this decree no longer applies so much nowadays and as such, it is customary to act leniently nowadays. The Poskim deal with this matter lengthily regarding whether or not we say that once the reason for the decree no longer applies then the decree is thereby nullified. (Some say that although tuning musical instruments is common nowadays, the original decree was instated lest one come to create a new musical instrument, which no longer applies that much nowadays.)

Halachically speaking, the Rambam (Chapter 23 of Hilchot Shabbat) and Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch (Chapter 339) rule that it is forbidden to clap one’s hands together on Shabbat lest one come to repair a musical instrument. The Rama notes on this point that nowadays there are those who are lenient in this regard and the reason we do not protest this is because it is better for people to do so unintentionally than to do so intentionally. This means that since those who are customarily lenient in this regard will not listen to us if we say it is forbidden, it is better to keep quiet and not to protest. He adds another reason for leniency based on the words of the Tosafot that the reason for the decree no longer applies nowadays and there is therefore room for leniency. (It is for this reason that several Ashkenazim and some Chazzanim of Moroccan descent are customarily lenient, for they rely on the opinion of the Tosafot.)

Even those who are customarily lenient and regarding whom the Rama writes that we do not protest, this only applies to clapping one’s hands; however, with regards to actually playing musical instruments, the Poskim (Sha’ar Ephraim, Chapter 36 and Maran zt”l in his Chazon Ovadia writes lengthily on this topic) write that there is only room for leniency regarding clapping. However, regarding actually playing an instrument, such as a whistle, bell, or drum, this is certainly forbidden even nowadays, even according to the opinion of the Tosafot.

Thus, halachically speaking, one should act stringently and not clap one’s hands together on Shabbat. This is especially true in Israel where the rulings of Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch have been accepted and since this is based on the words of the Rambam who was the chief halachic authority in all Middle Eastern lands.

Summary: One should not clap one’s hands on Shabbat. One should likewise not drum on the table to the rhythm of a tune on Shabbat. However, it is permissible to do so on Shabbat in an unusual manner such that this does not resemble the way one would do so during the week, such as clapping the back of one’s hand into the palm of one’s other hand or drumming on the table with the back of one’s hand.     

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

Se couper les cheveux et se raser pendant le ‘Omer

Ne pas se couper les cheveux pendant les jours du ‘Omer La tradition est répandue de ne pas se couper les cheveux pendant le ‘Omer. Selon la tradition Ashkénaze, jusqu’au 33ème jour du ‘Omer, mais selon la tradition Séfarade, jusqu’au 34&eg......

Read Halacha

Taper des mains ou taper sur une table pendant Chabbat et Yom Tov

Il est enseigné dans la Guémara Bétsa (30a): Pendant Chabbat, on ne tape pas des mains et on ne danse pas … Par crainte d’en arriver à réparer un instrument de musique (ibid.36b). Comme nous l’avons expliqué dans les préc&eacut......

Read Halacha

Jouets émettant des sons – Jouets fonctionnant avec un ressort

Question: Est-il permis de laisser des enfants jouer pendant Chabbat avec des jouets émettant des sons, comme une poupée qui produit un bruit lorsqu’on la secoue, ou autre? Réponse: Dans la précédente Halacha, nous avons expliqué qu’il est int......

Read Halacha

Emettre un son et siffler pendant Chabbat

Dans la Guémara ‘Erouvin (104a), on explique le décret de nos maîtres selon lequel il est interdit d’émettre un son pendant Chabbat et les jours de Yom Tov. Par exemple, il est interdit un jour de Chabbat ou de Yom Tov de jouer d’un instrument de musiqu......

Read Halacha


Prier en pyjama

Question: Est-il permis de prier en pyjama? Réponse: Il y a environ une semaine, nous avons expliqué que celui qui prie doit au préalable prévoir un endroit digne pour sa prière. Il doit aussi s’apprêter correctement au niveau de sa tenue vestimentai......

Read Halacha

Le « ’Erouv Tavchiline » - 7ème jour de Pessa’h 5782

Qu’est ce que le ‘Erouv Tavchiline? Cette année (5782), le 7ème jour de Pessa’h tombera un vendredi veille de Chabbat. Nous savons que pendant chaque Yom Tov (jour de fête comme Chavou’ot, Pessa’h, Soukkot, Shémini ‘Atseret Roch Ha-Cha......

Read Halacha

Se couper les cheveux la nuit du 34ème jour du ‘Omer cette année (5782)

Ce jeudi (depuis mercredi soir) tombe le 33ème jour du ‘Omer (Lag Baomer), et le lendemain vendredi, tombe le 34ème jour du ‘Omer. Jusqu’à quand dure l’interdit de se couper les cheveux? Nous avons déjà expliqué qu’il est i......

Read Halacha

Le H’amets pendant Pessah’ – année 5782 – L’institution de notre maitre le Rav z.ts.

Nos maitres enseignent dans la Tossefta (Pessa’him chap.3): « On questionne et on enseigne les règles relatives à Pessa’h 30 jours avant Pessa’h. » En se basant sur cet enseignement, les Rabbanim du peuple d’Israël ont toujours eu l’usag......

Read Halacha