Halacha for vendredi 5 Cheshvan 5781 23 October 2020

Parashat Noah - [Keeping the Torah With or Without the Peer Pressures and In All Circumstances]

From HaGaon Rav Zevadia HaCohen Shlit”a, The Head of the Batei Din in Tel Aviv
(translated by our dear friend Rav Daniel Levy Shlit”a, Leeds UK)

This Shabbat we read, “These are the chronicles of Noach, Noach was a righteous man, faultless in his generation, Noach walked with Hashem” (Bereishit 6:9).

Rashi HaKadosh z”l quotes the Talmud (Sanhedrin 108a) that there are those who explain this by way of a compliment and those who explain it by way of criticism. Rabbi Yochanan explained it by way of criticism he was righteous “in his generation”, specifically in his generation he was righteous, but wouldn’t have been considered so in other generations. So, if for example, he had lived at a time were there other righteous people, he wouldn’t have been considered special. Resh Lakish on the other hand explained it by way of praise. If already in such a wicked generation he was righteous, then all the more so had he lived at a time when he would have been around other righteous people.

This appears startling, since according to all opinions he was righteous in his generation, so why should anyone wish to denigrate Noach as what would be if he lived amongst other righteous people? We have a principle that a judge only has to consider the facts of what is in front of him [Bava Batra 131a], and since we see that in this current generation he was righteous, we should only explain this in a praiseworthy manner and why try and speculate what would be in other generations!

This may be explained as follows. Our sages taught us here an important principle. The measure of a righteous person isn’t calibrated simply by the situation he finds himself at that time and place, but rather based on the principles of the Torah – of halacha and mussar - as given at Sinai, without being influenced by the particular environment or peer pressure at any given time.

Sometimes a person knows that he only fulfils the mitzvot in a partial manner, or he only fulfils certain mitzvot that find favour in his eyes, or those he finds easy, or from his personal perspective, or from his understanding of things and as such, he knows that he is incomplete. However, he consoles himself that this is due to the people that he lives with now, be they family members or work colleagues. And so relative to them, he is a big tzaddik, since they keep nothing, and as such what he observes is perceived as considerable.

It wouldn’t be the first time, that even people who are considered G-d-fearing, that when they are at home and in their comfort zone that they display fear of Hashem and are meticulous in observing that which is less severe, just like they observe the severest aspects of the Torah. However, when they arrive in a different environment, which is less spiritual, less strong, for example when they go on an outing, are at work, or travelling, they allow themselves to descend spiritually, albeit temporarily. This is because the situation they now find themselves in, they are still considered completely righteous relative to those around them.

It is this that [some of the] the sages came to denigrate and explained in a critical way and considered Noach a righteous person only relative to his generation, at that time, with those people in which he found himself, but not truly from an objective stance.

And so, it is incumbent upon each of us when fulfilling the 613 mitzvot, according to the Shulchan Aruch, the less severe like the most severe halachot, at all times, in all circumstances and not based on peer pressure. Indeed, from such a perspective our sages will only explain our actions in a praiseworthy way.

Shabbat Shalom!

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

Tirer profit pendant Chabbat d’une chose « Mouktsé »

Question: Est-il permis de s’assoir pendant Chabbat sur des grosses pierres, et est-il également permis de s’appuyer sur une voiture pendant Chabbat? Réponse: Dans les précédentes Halachot, nous avons expliqué certaines règles concernant l&rsq......

Read Halacha

Principes généraux dans les règles de « Mouktsé »

Dans les précédentes Halachot, nous avons traité de manière générale la source de cet interdit, et nous avons écrit qu’il y a certains objets que nos sages ont interdit de déplacer pendant Chabbat pour les raisons que nous avons cit&......

Read Halacha

Le Seder de Roch Ha-Chana – « Réjouissez-vous en tremblant »

Pendant les 2 soirs de Roch Ha-Chana, nous avons la tradition de consommer certains aliments en guise de bon signe pour toute l’année. C’est pour cela que nous mangeons ces soirs-là, des haricots (Roubya en araméen ou Loubya en arabe), de la courge (Kr’a), du ......

Read Halacha

Déplacer des livres et des journaux le Chabbat

Question: Est-il permis de déplacer et de lire dans des livres de médecine ou dans un annuaire durant Chabbat, et est-il permis de lire des journaux le jour du Chabbat. Les paroles du Choulh’ann ‘Arouh’ à propos de la lecture de livres profanes et des livres......

Read Halacha


Déplacer de la viande crue pendant Chabbat

Question: Est-il permis de déplacer de la viande ou des poissons crus pendant Chabbat? Réponse: Dans les précédentes Halachot, nous avons expliqué le principe de l’interdit de déplacer pendant Chabbat une chose qui a le statut de « Moukts......

Read Halacha

Un objet destiné à une activité interdite pendant Chabbat

Dans les précédentes Halachot, nous avons expliqué les principales règles de Mouktsé pendant Chabbat, selon lesquelles nos maitres ont interdit de déplacer certaines choses pendant Chabbat. Les objets dont l’activité principale est autoris&eacut......

Read Halacha

« Mouktsé Mé-H’amatt H’essronn Kiss »

Dans les précédentes Halachot, nous avons expliqué les principales règles de « Mouktsé » pendant Chabbat, selon lesquelles nos maîtres ont interdit de déplacer certains objets pendant Chabbat. Nous avons appris jusqu’à pr&eacut......

Read Halacha

Déplacer une couverture électrique ou un ventilateur pendant Chabbat

Question: Est-il permis d’utiliser une couverture électrique pendant Chabbat, ou bien y a-t-il une interdiction de la déplacer d’un point de vue de « Mouktsé »? De même, est-il permis de tourner un ventilateur vers une direction pendant C......

Read Halacha