Halacha for Wednesday 4 Tevet 5780 January 1 2020

A Torah Scholar About Whom Bad Rumors Have Emerged

Question: If rumors emerge that a certain Torah scholar has transgressed several Torah prohibitions, is there still an obligation to honor him?

Answer: Rabbeinu Meir Ha’Levi Abulafia (known as the Ramah, a friend of the Ramban who also authored some Kabbalistic works, not to be confused with the later Rama as in Rabbeinu Moshe Isserlish) writes that all of the laws regarding honoring Torah scholars apply only to a genuine Torah scholar who is truly G-d-fearing; however, Torah scholars who are lax in Mitzvah observance and do not possess fear of Heaven are considered to be the lowest elements of society since they desecrate Hashem’s name and about them does the prophet Micha (Chapter 3) state, “Hear this please, heads of the house of Yaakov and rulers of the house of Israel that abhor justice and pervert all equity etc. Thus, because of you, Zion shall be ploughed as a field, Jerusalem shall become heaps, and the mountain of the house (Temple Mount) as the high places of a forest.” We see from this that a rabbi’s Torah knowledge is of no importance if he does not possess fear of Heaven, as Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch rules: “A Torah scholar who treats the Mitzvot lightly and does not possess fear of Heaven is considered like the lowest elements of society.” We have already discussed this point two days ago.

The Gemara (Mo’ed Katan 17a) discusses an incident where the Torah scholars of a certain generation required the Torah knowledge of a certain Torah scholar about whom bad rumors had emerged and had been excommunicated by Rav Yehuda as a result of these rumors. Although the students needed to study Torah from this individual, nevertheless, the Gemara there expounds the verse “For the lips of a Kohen shall keep knowledge and they shall seek Torah from his mouth for he is an angel of Hashem of Hosts” that if the rabbi resembles a Heavenly angel, then Torah should be sought from his mouth, but if not, one should not seek Torah from him. Thus, Rav Yehuda excommunicated this Torah scholar although he was needed to teach Torah to others since it was preferable for others not to study Torah from this individual because of the rumors that had emerged about him.

Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch rules as follows: “If a rabbi does not go in a good path, although he is a great Torah scholar and the entire nation needs him, no one should learn Torah from him until he returns to the righteous path.” The source for this ruling is the aforementioned Gemara in Masechet Mo’ed Katan.

Although the Gemara recounts that Rav Yehuda excommunicated a Torah scholar about whom rumors had emerged, nevertheless, the issue of excommunicating a Torah scholar is simple at all because of the exalted level of Torah scholars. Indeed, if an elderly and brilliant Torah scholar or the head of a rabbinical court sin, they may never be excommunicated in public unless they have done something to the extent of Yarov’am be Nevat and his colleagues; rather, they are told to preserve their honor and stay home.

Additionally, it is possible that a Torah scholar will sin and then repent fully at which point his sin will be forgiven. These issues are full of many fine details and the rule is that one must follow the instructions of the Torah leaders of the generation, for only they will be able to reach the true clarity of the matter.

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

The Customary Order of Rosh Hashanah

It is customary to eat certain symbolic foods during the two nights of Rosh Hashanah which signify good fortune for the entire upcoming year. It is therefore customary to eat black-eyed peas, pumpkin, leek, spinach, dates, pomegranates, apples dipped in honey, and meat of a sheep’s head on the......

Read Halacha

The Blessings on Thunder and Lightning

One who sees lightning recites the blessing, “Baruch Ata Hashem Elokeinu Melech Ha’Olam Oseh Ma’aseh Bereshit.” One who hears thunder recites the blessing, “Baruch Ata Hashem Elokeinu Melech Ha’Olam She’Kocho Ugvurato Maleh Olam.” Until When Can On......

Read Halacha

“And Your Camp Shall Be Holy”

Question: May I pray when my child is walking around the house in a dirty diaper? Answer: We derive from the verse in the Torah, “And your camp shall be holy”, that one may not recite words of Torah, pray, or perform any acts of holiness (for instance donning Tefillin) in the restroom......

Read Halacha

Women and the Shabbat Meals-The Custom of Maran zt”l

Question: Are women obligated to eat all three Shabbat meals as are men? Answer: In the previous Halachot, we have explained the primary laws regarding the Shabbat meals, including the obligation to eat three meals on Shabbat: One on Shabbat night, one on Shabbat morning, and one on Shabbat after......

Read Halacha


The Laws of Mentioning “Mashiv Ha’Ruach”

We Begin Reciting “Mashiv Ha’Ruach” “Mashiv Ha’Ruach U’Morid Ha’Geshem” is a praise we recite to Hashem during the winter months within the “Mechayeh Ha’Metim” blessing of the Amidah as is printed in all Siddurim. We begin recitin......

Read Halacha

Using Frozen Bread for “Double Bread”

We have already discussed that there is a Mitzvah to recite the Hamotzi blessing during the Shabbat meals on “double bread,” i.e. two loaves of bread. It is fairly common that one does not have two loaves of bread for this Mitzvah and would like to join a frozen loaf of bread from the fr......

Read Halacha

“Double Bread”

In the previous Halacha, we have explained the laws of Seuda Shelishit and would also like to discuss the laws of women regarding Seuda Shelishit. However, since this issue is connected to the laws of women and “double bread” on Shabbat, let us first discuss the basic laws of “doub......

Read Halacha

Speaking Between Washing One’s Hands and the “Hamotzi” Blessing

Question: Is one permitted to speak between washing one’s hands and reciting the Hamotzi blessing? Answer: The Gemara in Masechet Berachot (42a) states: “Immediately following hand-washing, one must recite the blessing.” The Rishonim disagree as to the explanation of this Gemara......

Read Halacha