Halacha for Sunday 13 Sivan 5778 May 27 2018

A Will to Disassociate from a Sibling

Question: Our deceased mother wrote a will and in it, she instructed us not to sit Shiva for her with one of our brothers, never to speak to him, and never to invite him to family occasions. We should point out that our brother is a good and G-d-fearing man and there were merely some side issues which caused his relationship with our mother not to be the best. How should we proceed?

Answer: The Rosh writes in one of his responses (Chapter 15, Section 5 quoted by his son, the Tur in Yoreh De’ah, Chapter 240) that if a father commands his son not to speak to a specific individual or not to forgive him for what he has done to him and the son wishes to make up with the individual but is concerned about his father’s will, the son need not be concerned about the father’s command, for one may not hate a fellow Jew until one’s sees the individual transgressing a prohibition. Thus, although the father has commanded the son to hate this individual, he does not have the power to instruct his son to transgress Torah law. Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch rules likewise (ibid. Section 16).

We see that although it is a Mitzvah to honor one’s parents during their lifetime and even after their passing, since abstaining from speaking to someone is a behavior exhibiting hatred and the Torah forbids Jews from hating one another, the son is therefore not obligated to listen to his father who instructed him to speak to another Jew. Only if the individual is a known sinner such there is a Mitzvah to hate him is there room to heed the father’s command and not speak to that person.

It is for this reason that when David Ha’Melech commanded his son Shlomo shortly before his passing to seek vengeance from Shimi ben Gera who cursed him, as the verse (Melachim 1, 2) states, “You must also deal with Shimi ben Gera the Benjaminite from Bahurim; he insulted me outrageously when I was on my way to Mahanayim etc. So, do not let him go unpunished, for you are a wise man and you will know what to do with him and you shall send his gray hair down to the grave in blood.” Indeed, Shlomo Ha’Melech heeded his father’s command, as is delineated in the following verse.

Since in the above situation, your brother is a G-d-fearing man and your mother’s anger and animus towards him does not justify ostracizing him from the rest of the family and it certainly does not justify instructing the family never to speak to him, you may not heed your mother’s will. It would be praiseworthy if you could convince your brother to attend the burial and request forgiveness from your mother in accordance with Halacha and from that point on, just continue on with your lives amid love, friendship, and camaraderie.

There is another Mitzvah here that you should be pursuing which is abstaining from strife and to act with love and unity, for the Torah wishes that siblings always remain loving and unified. We derive this from the fact the Torah prohibits one to marry one’s wife’s sister as long as the wife is alive, i.e. the prohibition to marry two sisters. The Torah (Vayikra 18, 18) explains that the reason for this prohibition is because the Torah wishes for two sisters to always live together peacefully and lovingly and not, G-d-forbid, for there to ever be any type of hatred between them. Since two women married to the same man generally do not love each other too much, the Torah therefore prohibited a man from marrying two sisters. The Ramban explains likewise in his commentary on the Torah (ibid).

Thus, even your mother, who is now in the World of Truth, has already come to the realization that her will is null and void as her instruction were skewed and she now wishes for you to all live peacefully together. On the contrary, doing so will cause her great satisfaction in Heaven.

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

The Month of Mercy and Forgiveness-The Month of Elul

Today, Sunday, is Rosh Chodesh Elul (the second of a two-day Rosh Chodesh), which is the beginning of the Month of Mercy and Forgiveness.    The Source for the Significance of the Month of Elul It is taught in Pirkei De’Rabbi Eliezer: “For forty days on Mount Sinai, Moshe R......

Read Halacha

Reciting Selichot Alone, Without a Minyan

Question: If one is unable to recite Selichot with a Minyan (quorum of at least ten Jewish men) for whatever reason or if a woman wishes to recite Selichot and she cannot do so with a Minyan, may one recite the Selichot texts alone or should one abstain from doing so? Answer: If one wishes to rec......

Read Halacha

What is the Most Preferable Time to Recite Selichot?

The prevalent custom is to recite Selichot during the early morning hours, i.e. at the end of the nighttime hours, before Shacharit prayers. Maran Rabbeinu Ovadia Yosef zt”l writes that the reason for reciting Selichot during the early morning hours is based on the words of the holy Zohar whic......

Read Halacha

The Law of “Entering One’s Boundaries”

In the previous Halacha we have discussed the prohibition to sit in close proximity to one praying Amida. We have also written that sitting in front or on the sides of one praying is an absolute prohibition along with the reasons behind this. “Entering One’s Boundaries” If one ......

Read Halacha


Sitting Within Four Amot of One Praying

Our Sages derived many laws pertaining to prayer from the incident recorded in the beginning of the book of Shmuel regarding Chana, mother of Shmuel Ha’Navi, who went to the Mishkan (Tabernacle) in Shilo in order to pray to Hashem that she be able to bear children. Through the power of her pra......

Read Halacha

At What Point During the Chazzan’s Repetition of the Amida May One be Seated?

In the previous Halacha we have explained that, according to the letter of the law, one may sit during the Chazzan’s repetition of the Amida. This means that after one has concluded one’s personal, silent Amida, the congregation may be seated and need not remain standing for the entire d......

Read Halacha

Changing a Name

Question: If one’s name must be changed for whatever reason, may the original name be changed completely or should one merely add another name to the original one? Answer: The verse in Parashat Bereshit states, “And whatever the man called any living soul is its name (forever).”......

Read Halacha

Reciting the “Asher Yatzar” Blessing in the Middle of Pesukei De’Zimra

Question: If one uses the restroom while in the middle of reciting Pesukei De’Zimra (the segment of the Shacharit prayer between “Baruch She’amar” and “Yishtabach”), when should one recite the “Asher Yatzar” blessing? Answer: If one feels that he mu......

Read Halacha