Halacha for Tuesday 1 Tammuz 5780 June 23 2020

Question: May one set an alarm clock to go off on Shabbat?

Answer: It would seem to be prohibited to set an alarm clock to go off on Shabbat based on the Baraita (Shabbat 18a) which states, “One may not place wheat into a water-operated mill (before Shabbat) in order for the wheat to be ground on Shabbat.” Although no forbidden work is being performed on Shabbat as the wheat is being placed in the mill before the onset of Shabbat and it will only be ground on Shabbat as a result of the water’s movement, nevertheless, since the mill produces noise on Shabbat, this constitutes a disrespect for the Shabbat. The Sages of the Talmud disagree whether or not the Halacha follows the opinion of this Baraita. Some conform this Baraita to all opinions and it will therefore be forbidden to begin any forbidden work before the onset of Shabbat if it will continue on Shabbat and produce noise. Others explain that this Baraita is contingent upon another related disagreement between Bet Shammai and Bet Hillel such that according to Bet Hillel, there is no concern with such noise being produced on Shabbat and it will be permissible to place wheat into a mill before Shabbat in order for it to be ground on Shabbat itself.

Halachically speaking, Maran Ha’Shulchan Aruch (Chapter 252) rules that “It is permissible to place wheat into a water mill shortly before the onset of Shabbat and we are not concerned that as a result of the noise, people will say that so-and-so’s mill operates on Shabbat.” The Rama, on the other hand, rules: “Some rule stringently regarding a mill and anything else which produces noise. We are indeed preferably concerned with this view; however, in situations of financial loss, there is room for leniency.”

Based on the above, regarding our situation, it seems that according to the Rama that one may not cause noise to be produced on Shabbat, it will likewise be forbidden to set an alarm clock to go off on Shabbat, for this constitutes a disrespect for the Shabbat as it seems that one is operating the alarm clock on Shabbat and causing noise to emanate. According to this, it will be forbidden for Ashkenazim to set an alarm clock to go off on Shabbat.

Indeed, Hagaon Harav Moshe Feinstein zt”l rules likewise in his Responsa Igrot Moshe (Orach Chaim, Volume 4, Chapter 70) and writes that Ashkenazim, who follow the rulings of the Rama, may not set an alarm clock to go off on Shabbat if it can be heard outside of the room it is located in. (However, if the volume of the alarm clock is not so strong and can only be heard within the room it is located in, even Harav Feinstein rules leniently.) We see that Hagaon Feinstein equates the law of an alarm clock to a vessel which produces noise on Shabbat.

Nevertheless, Maran Rabbeinu Ovadia Yosef zt”l (in a response printed in Yalkut Yosef, Shabbat, Part 1, page 89) quotes several Acharonim who rule that there is room for leniency in this regard, even according to the Rama’s opinion, for according to all opinions, if the noise is not heard immediately after the action the individual performs, such as regarding a mill, and is only heard later, there is no prohibition of producing noise here. Additionally, most people do not set their alarm clocks to go off every day; rather, it is already set to wake them up at the same time every day. If this is the case, there is certainly no room to prohibit setting an alarm clock for Shabbat, for the Poskim (quoted by the Bet Yosef in Chapter 338) that it is permissible before Shabbat to set a clock to go off and make noise every hour of Shabbat since everyone knows that such a clock is set once and no one sets it every day. The Rama himself quotes this as Halacha.

Thus, halachically speaking, it is permissible for both Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews to set alarm clock before the onset of Shabbat to go off on Shabbat. Hagaon Harav Eliezer Yehuda Waldenberg zt”l and other great Poskim rule likewise.

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

ORDEN RITUAL DE LA NOCHE DE ROSH HASHANA

Las dos noches de Rosh Hashana es costumbre comer alimentos que simbolizan buenos designios para Israel. Por ello se come Rubia o lubia en árabe, zapallo –calabaza dulce-, dátiles, acelga, puerro, cabeza de cordero, manzana y miel. Ya hemos escrito oportunamente, que la perso......

Read Halacha

COMO RETRACTARSE DE LAS CALUMNIAS HABLADAS

Pregunta: Es necesario, para poder retractarse correctamente, acercarse a la persona que se criticó –sobre la que se habló “lashon hara”- para aclararle lo que habló de él? Por otro lado, el rabino que dictaminó en forma rigurosa, prohibió ......

Read Halacha

TIEMPO DE LLUVIAS

Comenzamos a citar el párrafo “Mashib Haruaj…” en la plegaria de Musaf (adicional) de la festividad de Simjat Torá (shemini atzeret, fuera de Israel). No se trata de un pedido formal por las lluvias sino de una alabanza al Creador, por ello se denomina en el lenguaje......

Read Halacha

Y TU CAMPAMENTO SERÁ SEGRADO

Pregunta: Se puede hacer Tefilá -orar - en la casa si hay un niño pequeño dando vueltas con un pañal sucio? Respuesta: Está escrito en la Torá Y tu campamento será sagrado, y se refiere esto a la prohibición de estudiar o pronunciar palabras......

Read Halacha


EL ARCOIRIS

La persona que ve un rayo debe pronunciar la siguiente bendición: Baruj Ata A-donay Elohenu Melej Haolam Osé Maase Bereshit. Quien escucha un trueno debe pronunciar la siguiente bendición: Baru Ata A-donay Elohenu Melej Haolam Shekohó Ugburató Malé Olam. En ......

Read Halacha

ENCENDIDO DE VELAS EN ROSH HASHANA

El primer día de Rosh Hashana es costumbre encender las luminarias del Yom Tob –festividad- antes de la caída del sol, como se lo hace en la víspera de Shabbat. De todas formas, si no se encendieron las luminarias en la víspera de la festividad, podrá la muje......

Read Halacha

LAS NUEBES DE GLORIA

En el Talmud (Sucá 11) leemos que la Sucá nos recuerda la nubes de la Gloria divina que acompañaban al pueblo de Israel en el desierto. Asimismo nos relata el Talmud (Taanit 9) “Tres buenos dirigentes tuvo el pueblo de Israel –al salir de Egipto-, Moshe, Aharon y ......

Read Halacha

LAS MUJERES EN LAS COMIDAS SABÁTICAS

Pregunta: ¿Tiene la mujer la misma obligación que el hombre de cumplir con las comidas sabáticas? Respuesta: Ya hemos visto anteriormente que en Shabbat el hombre debe realizar tres comidas, cada una de estas con dos panes. Una en la noche de Shabbat, la segunda durante la ma......

Read Halacha