Halacha for Monday 27 Cheshvan 5780 November 25 2019

Cooked Wine

Yesterday, we have explained that a Jew who publicly desecrates Shabbat and touches wine causes the wine to be forbidden, similar to the law of a non-Jew. The question becomes, when a religious son spends Shabbat with his non-religious parents and they made sure to purchase kosher wine but the father insists on pouring the wine for Kiddush, how can one avoid the prohibition of consuming forbidden wine without insulting one’s father?

Cooked Wine
Cooked wine, i.e. wine which was boiled over a fire, does not become prohibited when touched by a non-Jew. The Poskim explain that the reason why our Sages did not forbid cooked wine is because such wine was uncommon during the times of the Sages and their enactment therefore did not apply to it. The Rosh writes likewise (there are other reasons for this which we shall not discuss at this time). Thus, it is clear according to Halacha that a non-Jew touching cooked wine does not prohibit it, as Maran rules in his Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De’ah, Chapter 123). Nevertheless, this only applies if the wine was cooked before being touched by the non-Jew, as we have explained regarding brandy; however, if the non-Jew touches the wine before it was cooked, even if it is cooked afterwards, the wine remains forbidden and may not be consumed.

Pasteurized Wine
The Poskim disagree regarding whether or not pasteurized wine (which is not actual boiling) shares the same law as cooked wine, for there is room to claim that only wine which has actually reached boiling point does not become forbidden when touched by a non-Jew but wine which has only been pasteurized cannot be considered cooked wine.

Indeed, Hagaon Harav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt”l rules that only wine which has been cooked to a point when its appearance has changed does not become forbidden; however, wine which was merely pasteurized and whose appearance remains the same is not considered cooked wine since even the non-Jew cannot tell that the wine has been cooked. He adds that according to the Rosh, the reason why cooked wine is permissible is because in those times, cooked wine was uncommon and the enactment of our Sages never applies to it. Nowadays, however, when cooked wine is very common, this reason should not be relied upon. Hagaon Harav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt”l ruled likewise.

After dealing with this matter at length, Maran Rabbeinu Ovadia Yosef zt”l rules that since our Sages never enacted that such wine should become forbidden, we cannot create new enactments of our own in order to forbid it. Although such cooked wine is quite common nowadays, since it was uncommon in the times of our Sages and their enactment subsequently never applied to it, it can never again become forbidden afterwards, for we do not have the authority to establish enactments the way the Sages of the Talmud did.

The Bottom Line
Halachically speaking, as long as the wine is pasteurized well, i.e. heated to a temperature of eighty degrees Celsius (or 176 degrees Fahrenheit), the wine can no longer become forbidden by being touched by a non-Jew (unless it is actually poured as an offering to an idol, in which case it certainly becomes forbidden by Torah law).

Regarding our question, there is certainly room for leniency if the son purchases specifically pasteurized wine, such as most grape juice on the market and other lower quality wines. In this way, there will be no concern if the non-Shabbat observant father wishes to pour the wine for him.

(When Maran zt”l served as Chief Rabbi of Israel, he instructed the Rishon Le’Zion Winery to pasteurize all of their wines to a temperature of eighty degrees Celsius, which would give the wine “cooked” status.)

Summary: Pasteurized wine does not become forbidden when touched by a non-Jew. It certainly does not become forbidden when touched by a non-Shabbat observant Jew. Similarly, if such wine was poured by a Jew who is not Shabbat observant, the wine is not forbidden for consumption at all and one may recite Kiddush upon it and drink it.

8 Halachot Most Popular

EL CUIDADO EN TODO LO RELACIONADO AL HAMETZ

Está escrito en la Tora (Shemot 13): Durante siete días comerás matzá y no se verás leudos y no verás leudantes en todas tus moradas. Y en el Talmud (Pesajim 21ª) estudian nuestros sabios que el hametz –producto leudo- no sólo está......

Read Halacha

CAZAIT MATZA - Pregunta: Cual es la medida del cazait que debe comerse de matzá la noche de Pesaj?

Respuesta: La noche del seder, se deben consumir según la halajá 3 medidas de “cazait”. Cada uno de estos “cazait” es de aprox. veintisiete grs. de matzá. De todas formas, existen opiniones que exigen cuatro y hasta cinco medidas de matzá, como ver......

Read Halacha

EL RELATO DE LA HAGADA

El precepto central de la festividad de Pesaj, es el relato que sobre la salida de Egipto debemos realizar la primera –y segunda noche fuera de Israel- a los más pequeños para transmitir la alegría por haberse consumado la libertad de nuestro pueblo. Comenzando la hagad......

Read Halacha

SEDER PESAJ –ORDEN RITUAL DE LA NOCHE DE PESAJ-

Es un precepto rabínico comer la noche de Pesaj “maror” –hierbas amargas-. Se cumple con esta obligación con distintos tipos de verduras amargas, sin embargo la costumbre generalizada entre las comunidades sefaraditas es consumir lechuga para cumplir con esta obligaci......

Read Halacha


HALEL LEL PESAJ

HALEL LA PRIMERA NOCHE DE PESAJ Enseña el Talmud (Tosefta Suca cap. 3): Dieciocho días y una noche se recita el Halel, a saber: Ocho días de Sucot, ocho días de Janucá, el primer día de Pesaj y su noche y el día de Shabuot. Y así tambié......

Read Halacha

SOBRE LA LECTURA DE LA MEGUILA

Cada integrante del pueblo de Israel debe cumplir con el precepto de leer la Meguilá en Purim. Esta lectura se debe realizar en la noche y repetirse durante el día, como refiere el versículo: D-os, clamaré a Ti en el día y no me responderás, y en la noche y ......

Read Halacha

HESEBA -Inclinación- - SOBRE LA CUARENTENA

En la situación en que estamos viviendo debido a la pandemia del corona, muchos se preguntan por qué D-os nos castiga de esta manera, qué tipo de pecado pudo acarrear tales consecuencias, de las cuales la más inmediata es el encierro al que debemos someternos. Lamentab......

Read Halacha

CONDICIONANDO UTENSILLOS PARA PESAJ - En relación a la pandemia que nos está afectando

---------------------------------- En relación a la pandemia que nos está afectando, hay un párrafo conocido en el Talmud (Guitín 56) que comenta sobre el emperador Titos, quien tras haber destruido y profanado el sagrado Templo de Jerusalén, se embarcó d......

Read Halacha