Halacha for Sunday 15 Elul 5778 August 26 2018

Taking the Customary Three Steps Back Upon Conclusion of the Amida When there is Someone Praying Behind an Individual

In the previous Halachot we have explained that one may not stand or pass in front of one praying Amida.

Let us now discuss the law regarding one who has concluded his Amida prayer and behind him stands another congregant who has not yet concluded his Amida. If, at this point, the individual in front were to take the customary three steps back marking the conclusion of the Amida, he will thereby be entering the four Amot of another individual who is praying.

Thus, if one concludes his Amida prayer and realizes that the person behind him is still praying, one may not take three steps back; rather, one must stand in place until the individual behind him concludes his Amida prayer. The same applies to women, especially during the High Holidays when the Amida prayers are longer than usual and one woman finishes praying while another woman behind her has not yet concluded her prayer; the woman in front may not take three steps back until the woman behind her takes her customary three steps back.

As we have discussed, this prohibition applies only when one enters the four Amot (6.5 feet) and when one will be standing directly in front of the one praying. However, if one does not enter the four Amot of the one praying behind him or if one is not standing directly in front of him and is on his side, one may take his customary three steps back and recite “Osseh Shalom.”

The Law Regarding a Chazzan
If a Chazzan concludes his silent Amida prayer but cannot take three steps back because there is a congregant still praying behind him but cannot wait since doing so will mean delaying the entire congregation, the Chazzan should not take three steps back; rather, he should immediately begin the repetition of the Amida and at the conclusion of the repetition, he should recite “Osseh Shalom” in an undertone and then take three steps back. If the Chazzan decides to take three steps back at the conclusion of his silent Amida and not to wait, he indeed has on whom to rely.

Summary: If one concludes one Amida prayer and there is another individual still praying behind him, one may not take three steps back until the person behind him concludes his prayer, for one cannot stand directly in front of one praying within four Amot. If the individual still praying is not directly behind him or if he is more than four Amot away (and even after taking three steps back, one will not enter his four Amot), one may take three steps back immediately.

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

EL PRECEPTO DE AMONESTAR AL PROJIMO, ESPECIFIAMENTE POR HABLAR EN MEDIO DE LAS ORACIONES

Continuamos desarrollando el precepto de amonestar al prójimo. La obligación de amonestar al otro no aplica exclusivamente cuando lo ve transgredir una obligación religiosa para con D-os –ben adam lamakom-, sino incluso en lo que se refiere a la conducta entre las perso......

Read Halacha

EL PRECEPTO DE REPROCHAR EN LA ACTUALIDAD

En las entregas anteriores hablamos sobre la obligación de reprochar al otro tanto si observa que comete un pecado ante el Eterno como si peca contra otra persona. Esta obligación se origina en el versículo que dice: Reprochar reprocharás al prójimo y no carga......

Read Halacha

KIDDUSH EN EL LUGAR DE LA COMIDA

Tras haber visto sobre el precepto del kiddush veremos a continuación más sobre la forma en que se cumple el precepto. No existe kiddush sino el lugar de la comida. Por ej. si una persona oye el kiddush de otra no cumple con su obligación si no come en el lugar en que oy&oacu......

Read Halacha

LLUVIAS O NIEVE QUE CAEN EN SHABBAT

Pregunta: La lluvia o la nieve que cae en Shabbat son consideradas “muksé” y por lo tanto prohibida su manipulación, o no? Repuesta: Existen en Shabbat cosas cuyo consumo está prohibido debido a que son consideradas “nolad”, o sea algo que su......

Read Halacha


KIDDUSH SOBRE EL VINO

Cuando pronuncia la bendición del Kiddush en la entrada de Shabbat, debe asir en su mano una copa que contenga la cantidad de un “reviit” -86 mls.- de vino. Dicha copa de enjuagarse previamente por dentro y por fuera y llenarla con vino apto para la bendición, es decir vino......

Read Halacha

Y NO HAS DE CARGAR SOBRE EL PECADO

Está escrito en la Torá: “Has de amonestar a tu prójimo y no has de cargar sobre él pecado”. Ya anteriormente hemos citado lo que escribe Maimónides al respecto. Dice el libro de los Proverbios: “el oído que oye el reproche de vida, entr......

Read Halacha

APODOS DESPECTIVOS

Como vimos anteriormente, existe una prohibición de apodar al compañero. Afirma el Talmud (Baba Metzia 58): Así dijo Rabí Hanina, todos aquellos que bajan al infierno suben (es decir todas las personas que por su accionar en la tierra son condenados en el juicio celest......

Read Halacha

TRITURAR VERDURAS EN SHABBAT

Como vimos en las entregas pasadas, existe una prohibición de moler alimentos –o elementos- en Shabbat y se trata de una de las 39 actividades prohibidas por la Tora en este día sagrado. Vimos sobre la prohibición de moler pimientos u otras especies, a menos que ocurran do......

Read Halacha