Halacha for Wednesday 22 Cheshvan 5779 October 31 2018

Grains of Salt or Sugar Which Have Clumped Together

Question: May one crumble a clump of sugar or salt which has crystallized as a result of moisture on Shabbat?

Answer: In the previous Halacha we have established that one of the forbidden works on Shabbat is grinding. It is therefore forbidden to grind spices on Shabbat. We have also written that if one requires spices, such as black pepper, for one of the Shabbat meals, one may grind on Shabbat as long as two conditions are met: One must grind with the handle of a knife (and not with the edge of the knife that cuts) and this must be done within a bowl. However, to do so using a mortar and pestle (utensils designated for grinding) is forbidden even when this is being done for the Shabbat meals.

Let us now discuss the law regarding clumps of sugar or salt which sometimes crystallize as a result of moisture. May one crumble them on Shabbat or not?

Crumbling Salt or Sugar By Hand
It will certainly be permissible to crumble them by hand or using the handle of a knife and in a bowl, for we have written that it even permissible to grind black pepper using the handle of a knife and a bowl. Indeed, the Agur (Chapter 488 quoted by Maran Ha’Bet Yosef in Chapter 321, Section 1) writes that those who rule leniently regarding pepper rule leniently with regards to salt as well.

If Two Variations Are Necessary
Nevertheless, the Acharonim disagree whether two variations are necessary when one grinds salt or if one is sufficient. This means that it is certainly forbidden to grind salt in a grinder, however, there is room for discussion regarding whether it is similar to pepper in that it must be ground using the handle of a knife and a bowl or if it is permissible to grind salt using a regular knife (the cutting edge) and a bowl. The Zivchei Tzedek proves from the words of the Rashba (in his commentary on Shabbat 141a) that there is room for leniency and one variation is sufficient regarding salt. The Rashba (ibid.) explains the distinction between salt and other spices (see Chazon Ovadia-Shabbat, Volume 4, page 251).

Salt Nowadays Which Has Already Been Ground
On the other hand, all this applies to salt which was originally one block; however, our salt which was already fine and then clumped together once again as a result of moisture may be crushed on Shabbat without any variation whatsoever since “there is no grinding after grinding,” meaning that there is no prohibition to re-grind something which has already been ground using a knife just as it is permissible to cut very bread into very thin slices on Shabbat (since the flour has already been ground). Only when one uses a utensil designated specifically for grinding is this forbidden, for it will appear to others that one is grinding on Shabbat.

Summary: One may crumble a clump of sugar or salt which has crystallized on Shabbat for use during Shabbat. However, one may only do so using one’s hand, a knife, or a spoon and not with a utensil designated for grinding (Chazon Ovadia-Shabbat, Volume 4, page 251).

Ask the Rabbi


8 Halachot Most Popular

One Who Eats Less than a Kezayit of Bread With other Foods- The Halachic Pitfall Present in Some Halls

In the previous Halacha we have explained that one does not recite a blessing on foods eaten during a bread meal, for the “Hamotzi Lechem Min Ha’aretz” blessing recited on the bread exempts them. We have also quoted the words of the Ritba who explains that this is not because of......

Read Halacha

Tu Bishvat Customs

Tonight, Sunday night, marks Tu Bishvat. There are unique customs observed on the night of Tu Bishvat, as we shall explain. The Prohibition of Fasting and the Customary Reading of the Zohar It is forbidden to fast on the day of Tu Bishvat. Some customarily hold an order of learning on the eve of......

Read Halacha

Mentioning Hashem’s Name in Invitations and Letters

Question: Is one permitted to write “ב"ה” (acronym for “Be’ezrat Hashem”) at the top of letters, adorn wedding invitations with verses, and the like or should one not do so out of concern that they may be thrown out into the waste basket, causing disgrace to Hashem......

Read Halacha

Eye Ailments on Shabbat

Our Sages teach us in the Gemara in Masechet Avodah Zarah (28b): “A man’s eyes are connected to his heart.” Thus, if we see that one’s eye is in danger, it is tantamount to revealing an ailment in the person’s heart and we must certainly rush to desecrate Shabbat in ord......

Read Halacha


Some Detailed Laws Regarding a Person Suffering from a Life-Threatening Condition on Shabbat

In the previous Halachot we have discussed that there is a Mitzvah to desecrate Shabbat for one whose life is in danger such as to transport him to the hospital, turn on a light in order to afford him proper treatment, and the like. We shall now discuss some details about this matter, based on what ......

Read Halacha

One Whose Life is in Danger on Shabbat

If one experiences a life-threatening situation or illness, there is a Torah obligation to desecrate the Shabbat on his behalf, for instance, by rushing him to the hospital by car; indeed, there is a Mitzvah to perform any other forbidden work on Shabbat that is necessary to save the individual&rsqu......

Read Halacha

The Blessing on Puffed Wheat and Farina

Question: We would like to partake of all of the Seven Species on Tu Bishvat. We wished to use puffed wheat as one of the species. What is the correct blessing on puffed wheat? Answer: Anything made out of the five types of grain (wheat, barley, oat, spelt, and rye) such as, cakes, cookies, and o......

Read Halacha

Rice Cakes and Puffed Rice Cereal

In the previous Halacha we have discussed that any grain, such as wheat, which is eaten raw requires the “Boreh Peri Ha’adama” blessing. For this reason, the blessing for puffed wheat is “Boreh Peri Ha’adama.” Only if the grains were cooked together until they sti......

Read Halacha