Halacha for Tuesday 16 Shevat 5779 January 22 2019

Eye Ailments on Shabbat

Our Sages teach us in the Gemara in Masechet Avodah Zarah (28b): “A man’s eyes are connected to his heart.” Thus, if we see that one’s eye is in danger, it is tantamount to revealing an ailment in the person’s heart and we must certainly rush to desecrate Shabbat in order to prevent his death.

Based on this, if one experiences eye pain on Shabbat and they emit certain discharges, such as puss and the like, or if one has a serious infection in one’s eye, one is considered to be ill with a life-threatening illness; based on what we have explained in previous Halachot, Shabbat must be desecrated on his behalf through rubbing some creams on his eye, boiling water for him, driving him to the doctor so he can seek treatment, and the like.

Nevertheless, according to modern medicine, no connection exists between the eyes and the heart and even if one were to incur a massive illness in one’s eye, this has no impact on the health of one’s heart. There is no reason to think that one may die from such an ailment; the worst case scenario is that the condition may cause blindness.

It is quoted in the works of the Rishonim that a certain maidservant’s (Mor Shmuel’s maid) eye was stricken on Shabbat and although she complained about the pain profusely, no one bothered to resolve the issue on Shabbat itself. The next day, Sunday, this maidservant died. After an autopsy was performed on her, it was determined that certain cords from her eye were connected to her heart and her eye ailment was indeed her cause of death.

Modern medicine rejects these views completely as we have already established and we must inevitably explain that human nature has changed regarding this matter as we find regarding many other matters that, without a doubt, many things were different than they are nowadays; we must therefore conclude that the reality of human nature has since changed in these aspects. It is well-known that in a matter of a few decades, many significant changes in the nature of humanity can occur. Thus, based on this, nowadays, one may not desecrate Shabbat for one suffering from eye pain.

Maran zt”l deals with this matter extensively and writes that some say that one should never accept the opinions of modern medicine and doctors against the tradition of our Sages who knew quite well that there is a correlation between the eyes and the heart and that an eye ailment may very well lead to death. The Poskim discuss this matter especially with regards to circumcising a child who is suffering from eye inflammation, for according to our Sages, the child should not have his Berit Milah until he recuperates, whereas according to doctors, there is really nothing to worry about. We rule in accordance with the opinion of our Sages and the child is not circumcised until he heals. Hagaon Harav Avraham Yitzchak HaKohen Kook rules accordingly in his Sefer Da’at Kohen where he writes that not only must the baby recuperate before the Milah is performed, but an additional seven days after the baby recovers must be likewise pass before the Milah is performed. Although Hagaon Harav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt”l is of the opinion that nowadays, Shabbat should not be desecrated on behalf of someone suffering from an eye ailment based on what modern-day doctors have said that this does not pose a danger to one’s life, nevertheless, when combining the opinion of some doctors even nowadays who say that such eye ailments do indeed pose life-threatening situations with the edict of our Sages, it seems that even nowadays, one may desecrate the Shabbat on behalf of someone suffering from an eye ailment.   

Thus, halachically speaking, let us quote the words of Hagaon Harav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt”l: “When one experiences a sharp and strong eye inflammation, sharp eye pains, an eye injury, or a severe loss of vision, Shabbat should be desecrated.” All this applies even if these symptoms occur only in one eye.

Similarly, if one sustains an eye injury on Shabbat and the retina of one eye becomes torn, he should be instructed to immediately drive to the hospital to save the eye from blindness. Similarly, one may rub creams on the eye on Shabbat or soak a towel with some hot water and other ingredients and place it on the eye on Shabbat; one should just take care not to squeeze the towel while doing so.

One may also act leniently and use eye-drops on Shabbat if one is unsure whether or not one has an eye infection since using eye-drops on Shabbat does not entail a Torah prohibition.   

Summary: If someone suffers from extreme eye inflammation, severe loss of vision, severe eye pain, or if one experiences pain similar to a poking sensation in one’s eyes and the like on Shabbat, even if it is only in one eye, one should desecrate Shabbat on his behalf in order to transport him to the hospital or anything else that is necessary to heal him. Additionally, one may use eye-drops on Shabbat for an eye infection, even if one is unsure whether or not one has indeed has contracted such an infection.

Ask the Rabbi

8 Halachot Most Popular

Question: May one discard of a Tzitzit garment or Tzitzit strings in the trash after they have been worn out and there is no longer any use for them?

Answer: Our Sages taught us in the Baraita in Masechet Megillah (26b) that articles which have innate sanctity may not be thrown out in the trash; rather, they must be buried respectfully with other articles of holiness. However, an item which has no innate holiness (and was used for a Mitzvah) need......

Read Halacha

The Attribute of Trust in Hashem-The Marriage of the Maharal of Prague

Question: Does trust in Hashem help even an individual who is not worthy of Hashem’s kindness? Answer: The Gemara in Masechet Menachot (29b) inquires regarding the meaning of the verse in Yeshaya (Chapter 26), “Trust in Hashem forever, for in Hashem is an eternal rock.” The Gema......

Read Halacha

Refusal to Appear Before a Bet Din (Rabbinical Court)

In the previous Halachot we have discussed that it is forbidden to go before either non-Jewish or secular Jewish courts to be judged. A very common question is: Since nowadays the rabbinical courts have no authority to obligate litigants to bring their cases before them, it happens that one may summ......

Read Halacha

The Status of the Secular Court System in the State of Israel

In the previous Halacha we have explained that there is a very grave prohibition for one to have a dispute adjudicated before non-Jewish courts. This is true even when their judges rule based on the laws of the Torah. This is also true even when both litigants agree to go to civil court. One who doe......

Read Halacha

Civil Courts

The Baraita in Masechet Gittin (88b) states: “Rabbi Tarfon says: Wherever non-Jewish secular courts are found, although their laws may be similar to Jewish law, one may not go before them to be judged, for the Torah states, ‘These are the laws that you shall place before them’- bef......

Read Halacha

Reciting the “Shehecheyanu” Blessing Upon Performing a Mitzvah for the First Time

Question: The custom in our community is that when a young woman reaches the age of Bat Mitzvah, she performs the Mitzvah of separating Challah for the first time and before doing so, she recites the blessing of “Shehecheyanu” as well upon performing this Mitzvah for the first time. Is t......

Read Halacha

The After-Blessing on Wafers, Baklava, Napoleon, and Bourekas

In the previous Halacha we have discussed that if one eats a Kezayit of cake which has even a minimal amount of flour mixed into it, one must recite the “Al Ha’Michya” after-blessing; however, this only applies when the flour makes up no less than one-sixth of the cake’s ingr......

Read Halacha

The Amount One Must Eat in Order to Become Obligated to Recite an After-Blessing

For any food one eats, one must recite a blessing before eating the food, such as the “Shehakol” or “Ha’etz” blessings. Even if one only plans on eating a small amount of that food, one must nevertheless recite a blessing before eating it, as long as one is consuming it......

Read Halacha